New Study Reveals Pivotal Role of Customer Experience (CX) in Driving Business Results

Watermark Consulting research finds firms that lead in Customer Experience financially outperform those that lag by a more than 3-to-1 margin in shareholder return

HARTFORD, Conn., Oct. 19, 2021 /PRNewswire/ — A new study reveals the significant payoff (and penalties) associated with customer experience quality in today’s marketplace. Widely loved brands with strong consumer feedback ratings enjoyed an average shareholder return that was nearly 110 points higher than the market index, while widely loathed ones lagged by an almost identical margin.

Watermark Consulting research finds firms that lead in Customer Experience outperform those that lag by a more than 3-to-1 margin in shareholder return.
Watermark Consulting research finds firms that lead in Customer Experience outperform those that lag by a more than 3-to-1 margin in shareholder return.

The data comes from new research conducted by customer experience advisory firm Watermark Consulting, which analyzed shareholder returns for companies that inspire customer raves versus rage. The findings reveal something that Main Street and Wall Street can agree on: A great customer experience helps build business value, while a poor one erodes it.

“The performance chasm between companies that lead and lag in customer experience continues to widen,” remarked Jon Picoult, founder of Watermark Consulting, and author of From Impressed to Obsessed: 12 Principles for Turning Customers and Employees into Lifelong Fans (McGraw-Hill, Nov. 2), in which the study is featured. “Over the long-term, beloved businesses are seeing returns that average 3.4 times greater than their less customer-centric competitors.” Picoult’s book explores the science-based strategies that CX-leading firms use to engineer such outstanding, loyalty-enhancing experiences.

The study vividly illustrates the vital role customer experience plays in business success.

“Many companies excel in frustrating their customers, whether it’s from a complicated purchase process, unintelligible assembly instructions, difficult-to-use products, hidden fees, long lines, or just plain poor service,” Picoult noted. “Our study reveals that businesses eventually pay a price for subjecting consumers to such indignities.”

Conversely, companies that consistently impress customers reap rewards – through increased loyalty, greater wallet share, stronger word-of-mouth, and a more competitive cost structure.

Picoult stressed that customer loyalty doesn’t arise by accident: “The businesses that do this well do it with great intentionality – relying on proven techniques to infuse their customer experience with simplicity, advocacy, emotional resonance, and other appealing qualities.” 

Many organizations are reluctant to invest in a better customer experience, questioning its ROI.  Picoult views this study as a much-needed wake-up call: “The payoff from a great customer experience is far from intangible.  It’s material and real. And if companies should be struggling with any question, it’s not ‘What’s the case for customer experience?’ but rather, ‘What’s the cost if we do nothing?'”

To learn more about the study and its results, view this white paper.

Several industry-specific versions of the study are also available, for Airlines,  Insurance, and Wealth Management firms.

About Watermark Consulting
Watermark Consulting is a customer experience advisory firm that helps companies impress customers and inspire employees.  Watermark has worked with leading brands, helping organizations capitalize on the power of loyalty in the marketplace and the workplace.  Learn more about Watermark’s consulting services, educational workshops or conference keynotes at www.watermarkconsult.net.

SOURCE Watermark Consulting

Author Information

As a detail-oriented researcher, Sherril is expert at discovering, gathering and compiling industry and market data to create clear, actionable market and competitive intelligence. With deep experience in market analysis and segmentation she is a consummate collaborator with strong communication skills adept at supporting and forming relationships with cross-functional teams in all levels of organizations.

Sherril holds a Master of Business Administration in Marketing from University of Colorado, Boulder and a Bachelor of Arts in Psychology from Rutgers University.

Latest Insights:
Platform Engineering for GenAI Is How Enterprises Move Past the Pilot Stage
November 16, 2026
Article
Article

Platform Engineering for GenAI Is How Enterprises Move Past the Pilot Stage

Mitch Ashley, Brad Shimmin, and Nick Patience at The Futurum Group share insights on why roughly 52% of organizations remain in GenAI pilots and how platform engineering moves AI into production....
Applied Materials Q4 earnings
November 16, 2026
Article
Article

Applied Materials Q4 FY 2026: AI Chip Demand Lifts Equipment Sales

Applied Materials reported Q4 FY 2026 revenue of $10.41 billion, up 53% YoY, as AI chip demand drives semiconductor systems revenue to $8 billion. Strong margins and earnings growth signal multi-year momentum....
Hitachi Vantara Unites Object Storage and Agent Control for Enterprise AI
November 16, 2026
Article
Article

Hitachi Vantara Unites Object Storage and Agent Control for Enterprise AI

Brad Shimmin, Vice President and Practice Lead at Futurum, analyzes how Hitachi Vantara VSP One AI combines four-node Iceberg lakehouse analytics with governed Model Context Protocol agents....
Why Autonomous AI Agents Require Zero-ETL Graph Engines Over Naive SQL Queries
November 16, 2026
Article
Article

Why Autonomous AI Agents Require Zero-ETL Graph Engines Over Naive SQL Queries

Brad Shimmin, VP and Practice Lead at Futurum, analyzes PuppyGraph’s 1.0 release and $10M Series A, examining how zero-ETL graph engines replace probabilistic Text-to-SQL errors with deterministic ontologies for enterprise AI agents....
Latest Research:
Google Public Sector Moves Agents from Pilots to Agency-Wide Scale
November 16, 2026

Google Public Sector Moves Agents from Pilots to Agency-Wide Scale

In our latest thought leadership brief, Google Public Sector Moves Agents from Pilots to Agency-Wide Scale, completed in partnership with Google Public Sector, Futurum Research examines the major themes and...
Converged by Necessity The Network as the Zero Trust Control Point
November 16, 2026

Converged by Necessity: The Network as the Zero Trust Control Point

In our latest thought leadership report, Converged by Necessity: Why the Network Is the Control Point for Zero Trust in the AI Era, completed in partnership with HPE Networking, Futurum...
Remediation Is Becoming a Software Delivery Capacity Problem
November 4, 2026

Remediation Is Becoming a Software Delivery Capacity Problem

In our latest thought leadership brief, Remediation Is Becoming a Software Delivery Capacity Problem, completed in partnership with Google Cloud, Futurum Research examines why the queue between a validated finding...

Book a Demo

Welcome

The vision behind everything in Futurum’s Custom Research practice is this: research should show you what is happening, what comes next, and what to do about it. It should be personal to each audience, easy for people to grasp, and structured so LLMs can reason over it accurately. And it should be fast and turnkey; you want answers now, not another project to carry for quarters.

Whether you are defining business, channel, or go-to-market strategy; evaluating vendors or justifying ROI; or commissioning research to fill an emerging market need, we have your back, with a program that answers your questions with the objectivity and credibility to drive real decisions.

To do it, we bring unmatched data to bear: Futurum research, surveys, and market projections; validated market feeds; ETR’s 15 years of insight from 10,000 technology decision-makers; G2’s buyer and user data; and what our analysts hear every day. Add leading primary collection, from AI-moderated voice interviews to surveys and analyst-led interviews, all turnkey, and every project comes out credible, nuanced, and actionable.

And we don’t just drop the results in your lap. For internal work, we provide analyst-led sessions, interactive dashboards, and a range of formats. For market-facing work, Futurum delivers turnkey activation and amplification that actually gets seen, by people and by LLMs, through our media and share of voice. This is research that moves decisions and markets.

We will meet you wherever you are, from a fast-turn brief to a multi-year program, and shape the work to your goals, timeline, and budget. The right program for your moment.

If any of this is useful, I would love to talk.

Benjamin Brown, VP Custom Research, Futurum Research

Benjamin Brown

VP, Custom Research · The Futurum Group

Newsletter Sign-up Form

Get important insights straight to your inbox, receive first looks at eBooks, exclusive event invitations, custom content, and more. We promise not to spam you or sell your name to anyone. You can always unsubscribe at any time.

All fields are required






Thank you, we received your request, a member of our team will be in contact with you.