New Benchmark Research from Incisiv and Genesys: Only 15% of Retailers Offer a Differentiating Experience When it Comes to Omnichannel Customer Service

While omnichannel customer service is a table stakes expectation amongst shoppers, the degree of service varies dramatically among both industry segments as well as individual retailers; big box, department store and specialty retailers lead the way for superior customer service.

JACKSONVILLE, Fla.–(BUSINESS WIRE)–As the buying journey has been forever altered, with it have come new expectations around customer service. While the retail industry has made significant advancements in providing better visibility into promotions and order tracking, it still significantly lags in expert assistance, order modifications post purchase and making shoppers’ order history available to customer service agents.

According to new insights released today by Incisiv, in partnership with Genesys, 1 in 2 brick and mortar retailers are Laggards or Followers in terms of omnichannel customer service. The Incisiv 2022 Omnichannel Service Index benchmarks top retailers’ ability to provide a seamless customer service experience across channels. Additional key findings of the report include:

  • 90% of shoppers begin their buying journey online, yet only 30% of shoppers are satisfied with the service offered during the discovery phase of the experience.
  • The department store segment leads the industry in enabling agents to provide assistance with product information.
  • The grocery segment ranks last in providing visibility into search history (only 13%) but leads all retail segments with buy online, pick up in store (83%).
  • The consumer electronics segment leads all of retail in offering the option to register and manage loyalty accounts (91%), as well as allowing agents to help shoppers with returns (100%).

This year, Incisiv recognizes 20 retailers and brands as Omnichannel Customer Service Leaders, including Ace Hardware, Bed Bath & Beyond, Best Buy, Macy’s, REI, Target and Walmart. The complete list of Leaders is available to download here.

“The past two years have impacted humanity in deep and transformative ways, including what we, as shoppers, value. Retailers will have to build and refine capabilities to serve these new expectations,” said Amarjot Mokha, Chief Operating Officer, Incisiv. He added, “Our goal with the Omnichannel Customer Service Index is to help retailers identify high-impact improvement opportunities based on a nuanced view of what drives superior customer service. Adopting foundational and advanced capabilities can help retailers improve their digital performance KPIs and competitive strategy by promptly adapting to consumers’ omnichannel service needs.”

The Incisiv assessment methodology spans over 110 measurable attributes across three areas of retailers’ service experience, including discovery, purchase, and 360-degree service. Attributes are categorized as table stakes or differentiating, based on their impact on key digital performance metrics such as average order value (AOV) and conversion. The index assesses a total of 102 retailers across eight retail segments.

Click here to download the complete findings from the Incisiv 2022 Omnichannel Customer Service Index.

Survey Methodology

The Incisiv 2022 Omnichannel Customer Service Index is based on insights from its proprietary digital maturity benchmarking methodology. The insights span 102 retailers, 110 digital capabilities and eight industry segments.

About Incisiv

Incisiv is a next-generation industry insights firm that helps retailers and brands navigate digital disruption in their industry. Incisiv offers consumer industry executives responsible for digital transformation a trusted platform to share and learn in a non-competitive setting, and the tools necessary to improve digital maturity, impact and profitability. More information is available at incisiv.com.

Contacts

Catherine Seeds
[email protected]
512.947.4062

Author Information

As a detail-oriented researcher, Sherril is expert at discovering, gathering and compiling industry and market data to create clear, actionable market and competitive intelligence. With deep experience in market analysis and segmentation she is a consummate collaborator with strong communication skills adept at supporting and forming relationships with cross-functional teams in all levels of organizations.

Sherril holds a Master of Business Administration in Marketing from University of Colorado, Boulder and a Bachelor of Arts in Psychology from Rutgers University.

Latest Insights:
Google Returns to the Frontier With Gemini 4 Argon
October 1, 2026
Article
Article

Google Returns to the Frontier With Gemini 4 Argon

Futurum’s Nick Patience and Fernando Montenegro share their insights on Gemini 4 Argon, Google’s new frontier model, and what its defender-first release means for enterprises and security vendors....
Docker Reruns the Container Playbook, This Time for Cloud Sandbox Kit
October 1, 2026
Article
Article

Docker Reruns the Container Playbook, This Time for Cloud Sandbox Kit

Mitch Ashley, VP and Practice Lead, and Vikram Rathnam, Research Director, Software Lifecycle Engineering at Futurum, on why Docker's Kit spec wins the agent control plane only if Kubernetes and hyperscaler runtimes...
Miro MCP Hits 16M Calls: AI Collaboration Goes Cross-Functional
October 1, 2026
Article
Article

Miro MCP Hits 16M Calls: AI Collaboration Goes Cross-Functional

Keith Kirkpatrick, Vice President, Research, at Futurum, Miro's MCP server exceeded 16 million calls since February 2026, with usage doubling since May and cross-functional adoption now outpacing engineering roles....
Salesforce Bets on AI Simulation to Defend CRM Dominance
October 1, 2026
Article
Article

Salesforce Bets on AI Simulation to Defend CRM Dominance

Salesforce's acquisition of Listen Labs embeds Agentic AI directly into its cloud platforms, enabling autonomous research agents and digital twins to compress customer research cycles from months to days across 50M+ global...
Latest Research:
When AI Is Everywhere, Data Becomes the Differentiator
September 30, 2026

When AI Is Everywhere, Data Becomes the Differentiator

In our latest Thought Leadership Brief, When AI Is Everywhere, Data Becomes the Differentiator, completed in partnership with Oracle, Futurum Research examines why industry-specific AI requires industry-specific data and how...
Where AI Delivers Real ROI: AI-First Integration and Orchestration
September 24, 2026

Where AI Delivers Real ROI: AI-First Integration and Orchestration

In our latest thought leadership report, Where AI Delivers Real ROI: How AI-First Integration and Orchestration Transform Workflows, completed in partnership with IBM, Futurum Research examines why AI delivers the...
From Pilots to Production: Why Agentic AI Runs Through the Ecosystem
September 22, 2026
Research
Research

From Pilots to Production: Why Agentic AI Runs Through the Ecosystem

In its latest report, From Pilots to Production: Why Agentic Transformation Runs Through the Ecosystem, published in partnership with Google Cloud, Futurum Research examines why enterprise AI spending keeps climbing...

Book a Demo

Welcome

The vision behind everything in Futurum’s Custom Research practice is this: research should show you what is happening, what comes next, and what to do about it. It should be personal to each audience, easy for people to grasp, and structured so LLMs can reason over it accurately. And it should be fast and turnkey; you want answers now, not another project to carry for quarters.

Whether you are defining business, channel, or go-to-market strategy; evaluating vendors or justifying ROI; or commissioning research to fill an emerging market need, we have your back, with a program that answers your questions with the objectivity and credibility to drive real decisions.

To do it, we bring unmatched data to bear: Futurum research, surveys, and market projections; validated market feeds; ETR’s 15 years of insight from 10,000 technology decision-makers; G2’s buyer and user data; and what our analysts hear every day. Add leading primary collection, from AI-moderated voice interviews to surveys and analyst-led interviews, all turnkey, and every project comes out credible, nuanced, and actionable.

And we don’t just drop the results in your lap. For internal work, we provide analyst-led sessions, interactive dashboards, and a range of formats. For market-facing work, Futurum delivers turnkey activation and amplification that actually gets seen, by people and by LLMs, through our media and share of voice. This is research that moves decisions and markets.

We will meet you wherever you are, from a fast-turn brief to a multi-year program, and shape the work to your goals, timeline, and budget. The right program for your moment.

If any of this is useful, I would love to talk.

Benjamin Brown, VP Custom Research, Futurum Research

Benjamin Brown

VP, Custom Research · The Futurum Group

Newsletter Sign-up Form

Get important insights straight to your inbox, receive first looks at eBooks, exclusive event invitations, custom content, and more. We promise not to spam you or sell your name to anyone. You can always unsubscribe at any time.

All fields are required






Thank you, we received your request, a member of our team will be in contact with you.